Insetting lets companies co-fund emissions reductions at their suppliers and keep the value as inset credits.
Customers share the cost of a supplier’s emissions reduction, and once a verification report confirms the result, each one receives its share of the credits to report, sell or retire.
Insetting keeps the money in the supply chain
For a retailer that ships goods, insetting creates new value on the route it already uses. Insetting reduces the emissions on that route. Offsetting pays for a project somewhere else and leaves the business’s own emissions unchanged.
Insets add to a company’s own emissions reductions and never replace them. Illustrative: fictional companies.
Scope 3 is a financing problem more than a measurement problem, because the reductions that matter most need capital that pays back.
Today, a customer that pays for a supplier’s emissions reduction gets nothing it can hold. With Carbon3 the cost is shared and the verified tonnes come back as inset credits.
With Carbon3, a supplier project that was a sunk cost for one customer becomes a shared asset for several.
An example from container shipping
This example follows a fictional shipping line and three fictional retailers that ship goods with it. Every number below is illustrative.
New to these terms? Insetting in 60 seconds
Where the emissions sit
Shipping line
Burns marine fuel on the route. These are its own Scope 1 emissions.
Retailers A, B and C
Pay to ship their goods on the route. The same emissions sit in their Scope 3, Category 4: upstream transportation and distribution.
The inset
The retailers co-fund a lower-carbon fuel on that route, so the reduction is inside their own supply chain.
What happens at each step
Scoping
The supplier and its co-funders define the project: the emissions source, the boundary, the baseline, the method and who pays what.
Who: Supplier and co-fundersRecord: Project scopeTiming: The first step, before anything is listed
In this example
The shipping line and the three retailers agree the boundary (one vessel on one route), the baseline (the emissions from the fuel the vessel burned in the year before the switch), the expected reduction, the method and the shares: 50%, 30% and 20%.
Validation report
A validator checks the scope, baseline and method before work starts, and confirms the project can be measured. Some projects also raise early funding from this point with future credits, which cannot be retired or used in a claim.
Who: Third-party validatorRecord: Validation reportTiming: Can begin before scoping is finished
In this example
A validation body reviews the plan. Its validation report confirms the baseline, the expected reduction and how fuel use will be measured.
Implementation
The supplier makes the change and monitors emissions against the baseline for the agreed period.
Who: SupplierRecord: Monitoring dataTiming: The longest step: it runs for the whole monitoring period
In this example
The vessel switches fuel. Bunker delivery notes, fuel use and voyage data are logged for the monitoring period.
Verification report
A verifier checks the monitoring data against the baseline and confirms how many tonnes of CO₂e were reduced.
Who: VerifierRecord: Verification reportTiming: Starts when the monitoring period ends
In this example
The verifier compares the fuel the vessel actually burned with the baseline year. Its verification report confirms 10,000 tCO₂e reduced, measured against that baseline.
Issuance
The project developer issues one credit per verified tonne of CO₂e on the Carbon3 registry, against the verification report.
Who: Project developerRecord: Issuance recordTiming: Soon after the verification report
In this example
The shipping line issues 10,000 realized inset credits on the Carbon3 registry, against the verification report.
Allocation
The credits are split between the co-funders in line with what each one paid. Each credit has one holder at a time and keeps its link to the project record, including the verification report, through every transfer, so the data trail stays complete.
Who: Project developer and co-fundersRecord: Allocation recordTiming: Right after issuance
In this example
Retailer A receives 5,000 credits, Retailer B 3,000 and Retailer C 2,000. Each credit still points back to the same project record and verification report.
Sale or retirement
Holders keep, sell or retire their credits. A retired credit is claimed once and can never move again.
Who: Credit holderRecord: Retirement certificateTiming: Whenever each holder chooses
In this example
Retailer A retires its 5,000 credits for its Scope 3 report. Retailer C keeps 1,000 and sells 1,000 to another holder.
- Illustrative: fictional companies, one vessel, one route and one monitoring period.
- The baseline is the vessel’s emissions in the year before the switch, and the verified reduction of 10,000 tCO₂e is measured against it. One credit equals one verified tonne.
- Shares of 50%, 30% and 20%, in line with what each retailer paid. No prices or fees are shown.
What stands behind every credit
Carbon3 keeps an audit-ready record of each inset credit, from the project evidence to the retirement certificate. The full method is on the methodology page.
What an inset credit represents
One quantified emissions reduction or removal of one tonne of CO₂e, inside a value chain, supported by project evidence and a verification report.
- Tied to one project activity, time period and system boundary in a defined value chain.
- A benefit that can be transferred or allocated before it is retired.
- It may count as a Scope 3 emissions reduction, depending on the company that retires it.
Carbon3 does
- Track issuance, transfers and retirement
- Record the allocation of credits between holders
- Produce audit-ready reporting outputs
Carbon3 does not
- Replace a company’s own carbon accounting judgment
- Guarantee acceptance by any standard or regulator
- Validate or verify projects: validators and verifiers do
Partner organizations make insetting a reality.
Insetting works when everyone works from the same record. These partners vary from project to project.
Validators and verifiers
Validators and verifiers act much like auditors: they check the data that project developers and MRV providers supply, and their findings go into the validation report and the verification report. Carbon3 never validates or verifies. It asks for a verifier that is independent of the project, but the registry does not yet check who wrote the report.
MRV providers
Measurement, reporting and verification (MRV) providers supply the monitoring data a verifier checks.
ESG advisors
Advisors help companies scope projects and fit them into their climate strategy and reporting.
Banks, lenders and industry bodies
Lenders finance projects inside real supply chains. Industry bodies share methods and data across a sector.
What happens during scoping?
The supplier and its co-funders agree which emissions source the project changes, the boundary (which sites, vessels or lines), the baseline the reduction is measured against, the method, and who pays what. The result is the project scope that the validator reviews.
How do the validation report and the verification report differ?
The validation report comes first, before the change is made, when a validator confirms that the scope, baseline and method are sound. The verification report comes after monitoring, when a verifier confirms how many tonnes of CO₂e were reduced. Future credits can be issued earlier, once the validation report is in, but realized credits are issued only after the verification report.
Who issues the credits, and when?
The project developer issues credits on the Carbon3 registry once a verification report is on file. The registry records, tracks and retires them. Realized credits are issued after the verification report, one per verified tonne. They are recorded in batches, each with its own record ID, and each issuance names that report. The project developer can also issue future credits earlier, once the project is validated, so funders can buy them to finance implementation. Future credits are labeled as such on every credit, cannot be retired or used in a claim, and the buyer carries the risk that the planned tonnes are not delivered.
How are credits split between co-funders?
In line with what each co-funder paid, as agreed during scoping. Carbon3 records the allocation, so every credit has exactly one holder.
What if fewer tonnes are verified than planned?
Realized credits are only issued for verified tonnes. Holders of future credits carry the risk that fewer tonnes are delivered than planned. How a shortfall is shared is set in each project’s agreement between the supplier and its co-funders.
Can a buyer count the credits toward its Scope 3 target?
When a supplier in the buyer’s own chain reduces emissions, the buyer’s Scope 3 goes down through lower supplier emissions data. The inset credit is the proof of that emissions reduction and who funded it, and it is not counted a second time. An emissions reduction outside the buyer’s own chain is reported separately, not as a lower Scope 3 figure. The Greenhouse Gas Protocol’s work on actions and market instruments is still in consultation, and a revised standard is expected in late 2028. Carbon3 builds to the strictest reading.
Can credits be traded before they are retired?
Yes. Credits can move between holders before retirement, and every transfer is recorded. A transfer does not change the verification behind the credit. Once retired, a credit cannot move again.
Let’s discuss emissions reductions in the supply chain.
Tell us where the emissions sit in your supply chain and who could share the cost of reducing them.