Skip to main content
Insetting 101

Carbon insetting pays for emissions reductions at the suppliers a company already buys from

Insetting means financing emissions reductions inside a company’s own value chain. This guide explains what it is, where the emissions sit, how a project and its credits work, and what companies can claim under today’s rules.

Published · Carbon3

What insetting is

Insetting means financing emissions reductions within a company’s own value chain. Each reduction is quantified against a baseline, independently verified and recorded so that each tonne is claimed once. The reduction happens at a supplier, carrier, farm or other partner the company buys from, so it lowers the emissions in that company’s Scope 3 inventory.

Three conditions separate an inset from other climate spending:

  1. Inside the value chain. The reduction occurs at a supplier, customer or other partner in the reporting company’s value chain.
  2. Measured and verified. The reduction is quantified against a baseline using a recognized methodology and checked by an independent verifier.
  3. Claimed once. Each verified tonne becomes one serialized credit, allocated by rule and retired permanently, so no two parties claim the same tonne.
Graphic titled Insetting: a working definition. It defines insetting as the financing of emission reductions within a company’s own value chain, quantified against a baseline, independently verified and recorded so that each tonne is claimed once, and lists three conditions: inside the value chain, measured and verified, claimed once.
The working definition used throughout this guide. Inset credits are not compliance units under the EU ETS or FuelEU Maritime.

Offsetting is different: it finances reductions or removals outside the value chain to compensate for a company’s own emissions. The comparison of insetting and offsetting sets the two side by side. Insetting adds to a company’s own emissions reductions and does not replace them.

Why Scope 3 is where the emissions sit

The GHG Protocol splits a company’s emissions into three scopes. Scope 1 covers direct emissions from sources the company owns or controls, and Scope 2 covers the emissions from the energy it buys. Scope 3 covers every other emission in its value chain, reported in 15 categories: eight upstream and seven downstream. Upstream examples are purchased goods and services (Category 1) and upstream transportation and distribution (Category 4).

Diagram of Scope 1, 2 and 3 as defined by the GHG Protocol: eight upstream Scope 3 categories on the left, from purchased goods and services to upstream leased assets, the reporting company’s Scope 1 and 2 in the center, and seven downstream categories on the right, from downstream transportation to investments.
The 15 Scope 3 categories of the GHG Protocol Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Standard. Inset projects usually sit in upstream categories such as 1 and 4, and in downstream transportation (9).

For most companies, Scope 3 is the largest part of the footprint. Across 2,229 companies disclosing to CDP in 2023, reported upstream Scope 3 emissions averaged 26 times their Scope 1 and 2 emissions, from about one times in fossil fuels to 92 times in retail (CDP and BCG, 2024).

Bar chart of upstream Scope 3 emissions as a multiple of Scope 1 and 2 emissions by sector, CDP disclosers 2023: retail 92 times, apparel 47, services 32, food and beverage 23, manufacturing 23, down to power generation 2 and fossil fuels 1. All sectors: 26 times.
Upstream Scope 3 emissions relative to operational emissions, by sector. Source: CDP and BCG (2024), companies with sufficient emissions verification.

Those same emissions are the supplier’s own Scope 1. When a supplier switches fuel, changes a process or adopts new farming practice, it pays for the change, yet the emissions reduction also appears in each of its customers’ Scope 3. Insetting lets those customers share the cost and hold an evidenced record of the reduction they helped pay for.

Where companies stand on Scope 3

Many companies engage with their suppliers on climate, but few set targets for supply-chain emissions. Of companies disclosing to CDP in 2023, 41% engaged with their suppliers on climate, 21% engaged and assessed supply-chain risks, and 15% had set an upstream Scope 3 target. Companies were 2.4 times as likely to set targets for Scope 1 and 2 emissions as for Scope 3.

Three square grids showing the share of CDP disclosers that have taken each step on Scope 3 in 2023: 41% engage with suppliers, 21% engage with suppliers and assess supply-chain risks, 15% have set an upstream Scope 3 target.
Share of CDP disclosers taking each step on Scope 3, 2023. The steps are not cumulative and not every company answered every question. Source: CDP and BCG (2024).

Rules are pushing Scope 3 forward. Under version 2.0 of the SBTi Corporate Net-Zero Standard, published on 11 June 2026, validations open on 1 February 2027 and the standard becomes mandatory for new target submissions from 1 February 2028. In the EU, the climate standard of the European Sustainability Reporting Standards, ESRS E1, includes Scope 3 emissions in what in-scope companies disclose. Disclosure creates the demand; insetting is one way to act on the emissions disclosed.

Two ways to spend the same climate budget

An offset pays for a project outside the buyer’s value chain and leaves its suppliers’ emissions where they were. An inset pays for a verified emissions reduction at a supplier inside the value chain, and the credits for that reduction are allocated to the partners that co-funded it.

Schematic of two funding flows. Offsetting: the buyer’s funding goes to an external project outside the value chain and supplier emissions are unchanged. Insetting: the buyer co-funds its supplier, the supplier’s emissions are reduced and verified, and inset credits, one per verified tonne, are issued to the supplier and allocated to partners.
Simplified. How each instrument may be used in a claim depends on the applicable reporting framework.
Illustrative bar charts of a retailer’s ocean-freight emissions before and after spending the same budget. Offset purchase: emissions unchanged, the retailer holds credits for a separate compensation claim. Inset project: the carrier switches to a lower-emission fuel, emissions fall, and inset credits for the verified reduction are allocated between carrier and retailer.
Illustrative example with no real company or figures; bar heights are schematic.

How an inset project works, from scoping to retirement

Every inset project on Carbon3 follows the same seven steps in the same order. Carbon3 is the registry, which means it records each credit and every change to it. It does not validate, verify or issue credits.

The seven steps of an inset project
StepWhat happensWhoRecord
1. ScopingThe supplier and its co-funders define the emissions source, the boundary, the baseline, the method and who pays what.Supplier and co-fundersProject scope
2. Validation reportAn independent body checks the scope, baseline and method before work starts. From here future credits can be issued to the project developer.Independent validatorValidation report
3. ImplementationThe supplier makes the change and monitors emissions against the baseline for the agreed period.SupplierMonitoring data
4. Verification reportAn independent verifier checks the monitoring data and confirms how many tonnes of CO₂e were reduced.Independent verifierVerification report
5. IssuanceOne realized credit per verified tonne is issued to the project developer, linked to the verification report and recorded on the Carbon3 registry.Project developerIssuance record
6. AllocationThe credits are split between the co-funders in line with what each paid. Each credit has one holder at a time.Project developer and co-fundersAllocation record
7. Sale or retirementHolders keep, sell or retire their credits. A retired credit is claimed once and can never move again.Credit holderRetirement certificate
Requirements vary by project type, methodology and verification pathway. See the methodology and how it works for a worked shipping example.
One verified reduction, three parties, counted once
PartyWhat it puts inWhat it gets
Supplier (project developer)Makes the change and receives the inset credits: future credits once the project is validated, realized credits per verified tonneCo-funding, credit payments or project finance that recover part of the abatement cost
Buyer (Scope 3 reporting company)Co-funding or payment for creditsSerialized credits and retirement records for its Scope 3 reporting
Investor (capital provider)Project finance, often by buying future credits earlyCredits backed by the project: future credits carry delivery risk, realized credits rest on independently verified reductions
Carbon3 registryRecords each issuance, allocation, transfer and retirement against a serial numberDoes not issue credits, validate, verify or hold funds
Schematic, not a specific project. Arrangements depend on the project and the agreements between participants, and claim treatment depends on the reporting framework.
A cleaner-fuel voyage, traced from bunker note to Scope 3 claim (illustrative)
StepWhat happensRecord produced
1. Fuel switchThe carrier uses a lower-emission fuel on a voyage co-funded by a cargo owner.Bunker delivery note and fuel certificate
2. QuantificationWell-to-wake emissions are compared with a conventional-fuel baseline.Voyage emissions calculation
3. VerificationAn independent verifier reviews the calculation and supporting evidence.Verification report
4. IssuanceOne realized inset credit per verified tonne of CO₂e is issued to the carrier, as project developer, and recorded on the Carbon3 registry.Serial number, for example C3-2026-000184
5. AllocationThe credit is transferred to the co-funding cargo owner.Transfer record
6. RetirementThe cargo owner retires the credit against a Scope 3 claim for transport emissions.Retirement certificate
Illustrative; not a specific route, client or agreement. Emissions on a well-to-wake basis. Inset credits are not EU ETS allowances or FuelEU Maritime compliance units.

What an inset credit records

One inset credit represents one tonne of CO₂e reduced inside a value chain. To hold up in an audit, the credit has to carry its own evidence: who it belongs to, where it came from, who checked it and what has happened to it since.

Illustrative inset credit record with serial number C3-2026-000184, one tonne of CO₂e, vintage 2026. Fields grouped as identity (serial number), origin (project ID, owner and site; methodology and baseline), assurance (independent verification body; verification report reference) and ownership and use (current holder; active or retired status; retirement date, beneficiary and claim).
Illustrative record; values are examples, not a real credit. Serial numbers are designed to prevent double issuance and double use.

Because every allocation, transfer and retirement is written against the serial number, a buyer, auditor or advisor can follow a Scope 3 claim back to the project and the verification report behind it, which is what “claimed once” means in practice.

Where insetting applies

Insetting fits wherever one company’s emissions reduction shows up in another company’s Scope 3. The table shows typical project types; real projects are scoped one by one.

Typical inset project types
SectorInterventionWho reduces emissionsWho co-fundsBuyer’s Scope 3 category
MaritimeLower-emission marine fuelCarrierCargo owner4 or 9: transportation and distribution
AviationSustainable aviation fuelAirlineCorporate travel buyer6: business travel
Steel and cementLow-carbon inputs and processesProducerManufacturer1 or 2: purchased or capital goods
Agriculture and foodRegenerative farming practicesFarmsFood company1: purchased goods and services
Industrial heatElectrified process heatManufacturerValue-chain buyer1: purchased goods and services
Battery materialsRecycled contentRecyclerElectric vehicle manufacturer1: purchased goods and services
Illustrative project types, not specific projects. The Scope 3 category depends on the buyer’s position in the value chain. Fuel producers and chemicals suppliers are covered on the low-carbon fuels and chemicals pages.

Where the physical product cannot be traced to a buyer, as with fuel in a shared bunkering or pipeline system, the environmental attribute can be traded apart from the product under a book and claim model.

What buyers can claim today

The accounting rules for counting a supplier’s emissions reduction bought this way are still being written. The GHG Protocol is revising its Corporate and Scope 3 standards and developing a standard on actions and market instruments. A consolidated draft for public consultation is estimated for 2027, and the revised standard for the fourth quarter of 2028. Until then, Carbon3 builds to the strictest reading, so the evidence is ready whichever way the rules settle.

  • When a supplier in the buyer’s own chain reduces emissions, the buyer’s Scope 3 goes down through lower supplier emissions data. The inset credit is the proof of that emissions reduction and who funded it, and it is not counted a second time. An emissions reduction outside the buyer’s own chain is reported separately, not as a lower Scope 3 figure.
  • SBTi’s Corporate Net-Zero Standard V2.0 keeps the physical inventory as the basis for targets. Projects and certificates that meet its integrity criteria can support target implementation, reported separately; carbon credits are treated under its Ongoing Emissions Responsibility framework.
  • In the EU, Directive (EU) 2024/825 applies from 27 September 2026 and bans product claims of climate neutrality based on offsetting. Inset credits support Scope 3 reporting, not “carbon neutral” product claims.

Claim treatment always depends on the applicable reporting framework.

Getting started

Four kinds of participant work from the same record. Project developers register a decarbonization project and receive credits for verified reductions. Supply-chain partners co-fund a project at a supplier and receive credits to retire. Credit buyers buy credits from verified projects. ESG consultants bring a client program to the platform.

Four ways in
ParticipantFirst stepResult
Project developer: supplier, producer, carrier or farmRegister a decarbonization projectReceives credits on the registry: future credits once the project is validated, realized credits for verified reductions, to allocate or sell
Supply-chain partner: brand, manufacturer or cargo ownerCo-fund a project at a supplierCredits allocated for retirement, with retirement records
Credit buyer: corporate or institutionalBuy credits from registered projectsSerialized credits with a full transfer record
ESG consultant: adviser to buyers or suppliersBring a client program to the platformSerialized records for client reporting
There is no fee to list a project or issue credits; a commission applies on trades and retirements (fee terms confirmed by Carbon3 management, 11 October 2026).

The solutions for suppliers, for buyers and for investors describe each route, and the free Data Hub shows the public emissions, targets and projects behind any company.

Key terms

Eight definitions on cards: Scope 3, value chain, insetting, offsetting, inset credit, baseline, retirement and book and claim.
Definitions as used by Carbon3. The glossary has every term in one line each, and book and claim has its own guide.

Insetting through Carbon3

Carbon3 is a registry and marketplace for inset credits. Credits are issued to project developers after an independent verifier confirms the tonnes, or as future credits once the project is validated. Carbon3 records each credit through allocation, transfer, sale and retirement, so every claim can be traced to its project.

To discuss a supply chain, contact us or list a project.

Questions

What is carbon insetting?

Carbon insetting means financing emissions reductions inside a company’s own value chain, at suppliers, carriers or farms it buys from. Each reduction is measured against a baseline, independently verified and recorded so that each tonne is claimed once.

How is insetting different from offsetting?

An offset pays for a project outside the buyer’s value chain to compensate for its emissions. An inset pays for an emissions reduction inside it, so the reduction appears in the buyer’s own Scope 3. The comparison page covers the differences in detail.

Who receives inset credits when they are issued?

Credits are issued to the project developer. Realized credits are issued after the independent verification report, one per verified tonne; future credits can be issued earlier, once the project is validated. Carbon3 is the registry that records, tracks and retires them, and never issues credits itself.

Can a company count inset credits toward its Scope 3 target?

When a supplier in the buyer’s own chain reduces emissions, the buyer’s Scope 3 goes down through lower supplier emissions data. The inset credit is the proof of that emissions reduction and who funded it, and it is not counted a second time. An emissions reduction outside the buyer’s own chain is reported separately, not as a lower Scope 3 figure. The GHG Protocol’s work on actions and market instruments is still in consultation; its revised standard is estimated for the fourth quarter of 2028.

Are inset credits compliance units?

No. Inset credits are not EU ETS allowances or FuelEU Maritime compliance units, and they do not support product claims of carbon neutrality.

Sources

  1. CDP and BCG, Scope 3 Upstream: Big Challenges, Simple Remedies (2024), press release. 26 times average, sector multiples, 41%, 21%, 15% and 2.4 times
  2. GHG Protocol, Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Accounting and Reporting Standard. Scopes and the 15 categories
  3. GHG Protocol, Consolidated Corporate Standard: Standard Development Plan (29 July 2026). Consultation draft estimated Q2 2027; revised standard estimated Q4 2028
  4. SBTi, Corporate Net-Zero Standard Version 2.0 (June 2026). Published 11 June 2026; validations from 1 February 2027; mandatory from 1 February 2028
  5. Directive (EU) 2024/825 on empowering consumers for the green transition. Applies from 27 September 2026
  6. Carbon3 methodology. Credit lifecycle, record trail and future credits

The Carbon3 Newsletter

Weekly analysis of industrial decarbonization and insetting across Scope 1 to 3, from the Carbon3 team.